Top 21 Auto Insurance Companies in New York

4 min read

Get started

Trusted by data-driven investors

This article explores the Top 21 Auto Insurance Companies in New York, highlighting their unique strengths and offerings. From independent agencies like Peters Insurance Agency, which provides personalized service and tailored coverage, to innovative brokers like New York Motor Insurance that utilize comparison tools for best rates, these firms cater to a variety of needs. Specializations range from auto insurance to business protection, all focused on delivering exceptional service and competitive pricing in the New York market.

New York Motor Insurance logo

New York Motor Insurance

🇺🇸 154 Grand St New York, NY 10013, US

Specializing in auto insurance, this innovative insurance broker utilizes a comparison tool to help customers find the best rates, aiming to lower car insurance costs for New Yorkers.

insurance
auto
car
quotes
comparison
broker
rates
savings
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2011
Blue Line Insurance Agency logo

Blue Line Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 55 Barn Road Suite 204 Lake Placid, New York 12946, US

Blue Line Insurance Agency is an independent insurance provider specializing in a comprehensive range of personal and commercial insurance coverages, including auto, homeowners, and life insurance. Their innovative approach features a dedicated team of experts who work collaboratively to deliver tailored solutions and efficient service to clients.

insurance
personal insurance
auto insurance
homeowners insurance
motorcycle insurance
boat insurance
renters insurance
umbrella insurance
life insurance
general liability
workers compensation
disability insurance
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 2011

Specializing in a wide range of insurance products, this firm offers life, auto, health, and home insurance, providing free quotes to help customers find the most affordable options. Their innovative approach includes personalized pricing based on various factors, ensuring tailored coverage for diverse needs.

life insurance
auto insurance
health insurance
home insurance
insurance quotes
risk assessment
coverage options
premium rates
Company size: 1

This firm specializes in providing a range of insurance products, including life, auto, health, and home insurance, with an emphasis on offering competitive quotes tailored to individual needs. Its innovative approach allows customers to easily compare options and find the most affordable coverage across multiple states.

life insurance
auto insurance
health insurance
home insurance
insurance quotes
premium rates
risk assessment
coverage options
Company size: 1

Eric A. Funk Agency specializes in providing tailored insurance solutions for both individuals and businesses, with a strong emphasis on sectors such as construction, auto service, and restaurants. Established in 1976, it distinguishes itself through its comprehensive coverage options and expertise in niche markets.

insurance
construction
commercial auto
personal insurance
restaurant
specialty trade
coverage
tailored solutions
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 1976
Albion Agencies Insurance logo

Albion Agencies Insurance

🇺🇸 30 N Main St Albion, New York 14411, US

Albion Agencies Insurance is an independent insurance agency specializing in a comprehensive range of coverage options, including auto, home, and life insurance, with a strong focus on competitive pricing and exceptional customer service. With over 175 years of experience, it emphasizes a locally oriented approach while serving multiple regions in New York.

insurance
coverage
auto insurance
home insurance
flood insurance
life insurance
long-term care
recreational vehicle
community service
competitive pricing
Company size: 2-10
ASAP Insurance Brokerage logo

ASAP Insurance Brokerage

🇺🇸 200 Broadhollow Rd Suite 207

ASAP Insurance Brokerage specializes in providing a comprehensive range of insurance solutions, including trucking, auto, home, and business insurance. As independent agents, they prioritize client needs by offering tailored coverage options from a selection of reputable carriers, ensuring competitive pricing and exceptional service.

trucking insurance
auto insurance
home insurance
business insurance
commercial auto
independent agents
insurance brokerage
personal lines
commercial lines
Company size: 2-10
Kolcun Insurance Agency logo

Kolcun Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 144 N. Jensen Road Vestal, NY 13850, US

An independent insurance agency specializing in a wide range of insurance products, including auto, home, business, and recreational vehicle coverage. It offers a unique service by providing multiple insurance quotes through a single call, simplifying the shopping process for customers while ensuring competitive rates and comprehensive coverage.

insurance
auto
homeowners
business
umbrella
motorcycle
classic car
recreational vehicle
quotes
independent agency
Company size: 2-10
Andrews Agency Insurance logo

Andrews Agency Insurance

🇺🇸 804 W State St Ithaca, New York 14850, US

Andrews Agency Insurance specializes in providing personalized insurance solutions across various sectors, including personal and commercial insurance. With a focus on exceptional customer service and integrity, they prioritize client satisfaction and foster strong relationships through dedicated teams of experts.

insurance
personal insurance
commercial insurance
auto insurance
homeowners insurance
business insurance
agribusiness
farm insurance
property insurance
client service
risk management
coverage options
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 1991
The Northwoods Corporation logo

The Northwoods Corporation

🇺🇸 8810 Main Street Williamsville, NY 14221, US

An independent insurance agency specializing in property and casualty insurance, offering a wide range of products for personal and commercial clients through partnerships with over 75 national and regional carriers. Known for its comprehensive insurance package programs and extensive presence in the western New York area, it stands out as one of the largest independent agencies in the region.

insurance
property insurance
casualty insurance
auto insurance
home insurance
business insurance
commercial insurance
independent agency
insurance carriers
insurance programs
risk management
Company size: 51-200
Founded: 1994
Empire Insurance Agency logo

Empire Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 4100 vestal road suite 102

Empire Insurance Agency is an independent insurance provider specializing in a wide range of coverage options, including auto, home, business, and life insurance. Its unique approach allows agents to customize policies from multiple insurers, ensuring tailored solutions that meet the specific needs of clients.

insurance
auto
home
business
renters
boat
motorcycle
life
flood
collector car
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 2009
Peters Insurance Agency logo

Peters Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 3306 Spring Court North Tonawanda, New York 14120, US

An independent insurance agency specializing in auto, home, and business insurance, offering clients tailored coverage options from a select group of reputable carriers. Their client-focused approach ensures dedicated support during claims, emphasizing fair and prompt service.

insurance
independent agents
auto insurance
home insurance
business insurance
coverage
claims assistance
competitive pricing
insurance carriers
Company size: 1
Founded: 2015
Curran Cooney Penny Agency logo

Curran Cooney Penny Agency

🇺🇸 11 Powerhouse Rd Roslyn Heights, New York 11577-1337, US

Curran Cooney Penny Agency specializes in a wide range of insurance solutions, including business, homeowners, and automobile coverage, as well as group medical and Medicare supplement insurance. Their comprehensive offerings cater to diverse needs, positioning them as a versatile provider in the insurance industry.

insurance
business insurance
homeowners insurance
automobile insurance
medical insurance
Medicare
workers compensation
commercial auto
building insurance
yacht insurance
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1991
Sid G. Spear Insurance Agency logo

Sid G. Spear Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 313 W Main St Malone, New York 12953, US

Sid G. Spear Insurance Agency specializes in providing a comprehensive range of personal and commercial insurance solutions, including auto, homeowners, life, and business insurance. Their dedicated team of experts ensures personalized service, helping clients navigate and secure the best rates available.

insurance
personal insurance
auto insurance
homeowners insurance
life insurance
health insurance
motorcycle insurance
business insurance
commercial insurance
general liability
workers compensation
group health insurance
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1912
The Lyden Group logo

The Lyden Group

🇺🇸 282 Ushers Rd Clifton Park, New York 12065, US

An independent insurance broker specializing in workers' compensation, auto, homeowners, and commercial insurance, dedicated to providing personalized service and competitive coverage options for clients across various sectors.

insurance
workers' compensation
auto insurance
homeowners insurance
commercial insurance
personal insurance
business insurance
renter's insurance
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 2002

Specializing in a wide range of insurance products, this firm provides life, auto, health, and home insurance with a focus on personalized quotes to help clients find the most affordable options. Its innovative approach includes leveraging various factors, such as vehicle type and age, to tailor coverage and pricing effectively.

life insurance
auto insurance
health insurance
home insurance
insurance quotes
risk assessment
premium calculation
coverage options
Company size: 1
Skeele Insurance Agency logo

Skeele Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 1715 Albany St. PO Box 459

An independent insurance agency specializing in a wide range of coverage options, including auto, home, and business insurance, while leveraging partnerships with multiple reputable insurers to offer tailored solutions at competitive prices. Their innovative approach focuses on prioritizing client needs over any single insurer, ensuring optimal coverage for diverse situations.

insurance
auto
home
business
motorcycle
umbrella
boat
renters
commercial
life
health
small business
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1957
VanScoter Insurance Agency, LLC logo

VanScoter Insurance Agency, LLC

🇺🇸 1577 Ridge Road West , Suite 216 Rochester, New York 14615, US

VanScoter Insurance Agency specializes in a diverse range of insurance products, including business, auto, home, and recreational vehicle coverage. With a unique approach that emphasizes comprehensive protection beyond its name, it caters to various insurance needs through innovative solutions.

insurance
business insurance
auto insurance
home insurance
landlord insurance
boat insurance
RV insurance
snowmobile insurance
motorcycle insurance
workers compensation
disability insurance
life insurance
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2005

Specializing in various types of insurance including life, auto, health, and home, this firm offers free quotes to help clients find the most cost-effective options tailored to their individual needs. Its innovative approach emphasizes personalized service based on factors such as age and vehicle type, enhancing the insurance selection process.

life insurance
auto insurance
health insurance
home insurance
insurance quotes
risk assessment
premium calculation
coverage options
liability insurance
underwriting
Company size: 1
The Insurance House logo

The Insurance House

🇺🇸 257-17 Hillside Avenue Floral Park, New York 11004, US

An independent insurance agency specializing in both personal and commercial insurance, offering a wide range of affordable and reliable coverage options from multiple trusted carriers. Its unique approach allows for tailored solutions by researching and comparing policies, ensuring clients find the best fit for their needs.

insurance
independent brokerage
personal insurance
commercial insurance
homeowners insurance
auto insurance
flood insurance
life insurance
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1976
Insurance Depot Inc. logo

Insurance Depot Inc.

🇺🇸 7603 5th ave brooklyn, new york 11209, US

Insurance Depot specializes in providing a wide range of affordable auto and home insurance solutions across nearly all U.S. states, utilizing a unique approach of shopping major carriers to secure low-cost rates and maximum benefits. The firm also offers specialized programs for various vehicle types, including exotic and classic cars, as well as tailored options for teen drivers and those with driving citations.

insurance
auto
home
commercial
workers compensation
vehicle
discounts
benefits
teen drivers
exotic cars
sports cars
hybrid insurance
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1999

Updated on

Let our AI browse all websites for you

Save time, improve accuracy, and get ahead of the competition with Cenco.ai.

Get started

You might be interested in