Top 21 Auto Insurance Companies in New York

4 min read

Get started

Trusted by data-driven investors

This article explores the Top 21 Auto Insurance Companies in New York, highlighting their unique strengths and offerings. From independent agencies like Peters Insurance Agency, which provides personalized service and tailored coverage, to innovative brokers like New York Motor Insurance that utilize comparison tools for best rates, these firms cater to a variety of needs. Specializations range from auto insurance to business protection, all focused on delivering exceptional service and competitive pricing in the New York market.

Kolcun Insurance Agency logo

Kolcun Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 144 N. Jensen Road Vestal, NY 13850, US

An independent insurance agency specializing in a wide range of insurance products, including auto, home, business, and recreational vehicle coverage. It offers a unique service by providing multiple insurance quotes through a single call, simplifying the shopping process for customers while ensuring competitive rates and comprehensive coverage.

insurance
auto
homeowners
business
umbrella
motorcycle
classic car
recreational vehicle
quotes
independent agency
Company size: 2-10
Finger Lakes Insurance Agency logo

Finger Lakes Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 Skaneateles, NY 13152, US

A full-service independent insurance agency specializing in custom-tailored coverage for classic and high-performance vehicles, boats, and power sports. It offers a concierge approach to auto insurance, catering specifically to enthusiasts and collectors.

insurance
auto
classic car
coverage
motorsports
powersports
independent agency
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2020
Primetime Affordable Auto Insurance Buffalo, NY logo

Primetime Affordable Auto Insurance Buffalo, NY

🇺🇸 1022 Broadway Buffalo, NY 14212, US

Primetime Affordable Auto Insurance specializes in innovative strategies to help customers reduce their car insurance premiums by leveraging industry practices to obtain more competitive quotes.

auto insurance
premium reduction
insurance quotes
cost savings
risk assessment
coverage options
claims assistance
Company size: 11-50
The Insurance Girl Brokerage logo

The Insurance Girl Brokerage

🇺🇸 4512 Church Avenue Brooklyn, NY 11203, US

Specializing in a comprehensive range of insurance services, this brokerage offers tailored solutions for businesses and individuals across various sectors, including unique niches like marijuana and film production insurance. Their innovative approach includes catering to specific contracting requirements and providing high-limit coverage options to meet diverse client needs.

insurance
brokerage
commercial liability
workers compensation
property insurance
health insurance
disability insurance
life insurance
film insurance
entertainment insurance
business insurance
marijuana insurance
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2015
Rodriguez Insurance Agency logo

Rodriguez Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 2995 Merrick Rd Bellmore NY, 11710, US

Rodriguez Insurance Agency specializes in providing a range of insurance solutions, including auto, home, life, and business insurance, with a focus on personalized service and extensive industry experience. The agency stands out by offering bilingual support, catering to diverse client needs with tailored insurance policies.

insurance
auto
home
life
business
policy
coverage
agents
claims
underwriting
risk management
Company size: 51-200
Aegis General Insurance - Specialty Dealer Division logo

Aegis General Insurance - Specialty Dealer Division

🇺🇸 343 Maple Ave Westbury, New York 11590, US

Aegis General Insurance - Specialty Dealer Division offers tailored insurance solutions specifically for used and new auto, truck, RV, and motorcycle dealers, focusing on the unique needs of the automotive retail industry. Their innovative approach provides specialized coverage designed to protect dealers in a dynamic market.

insurance
specialty insurance
auto dealers
used car dealers
garage coverage
RV insurance
motorcycle insurance
tailored coverage
Company size: 501-1000
Founded: 2021
ASAP Insurance Brokerage logo

ASAP Insurance Brokerage

🇺🇸 200 Broadhollow Rd Suite 207

ASAP Insurance Brokerage specializes in providing a comprehensive range of insurance solutions, including trucking, auto, home, and business insurance. As independent agents, they prioritize client needs by offering tailored coverage options from a selection of reputable carriers, ensuring competitive pricing and exceptional service.

trucking insurance
auto insurance
home insurance
business insurance
commercial auto
independent agents
insurance brokerage
personal lines
commercial lines
Company size: 2-10
Kinowski Agency Inc logo

Kinowski Agency Inc

🇺🇸 478 Locust Ave Amsterdam, New York 12010, US

A family-run insurance provider specializing in a comprehensive range of coverage options, including auto, home, life, and business insurance, with a strong emphasis on personalized service and decades of industry experience.

insurance
auto
home
life
business
commercial
renters
umbrella
recreational
motorcycle
boat
classic car
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 1959
JD Chapman Agency Inc logo

JD Chapman Agency Inc

🇺🇸 66 Main St Macedon, N 14502, US

JD Chapman Agency specializes in providing comprehensive insurance solutions for both businesses and individuals, focusing on a wide range of commercial and personal lines. Their innovative approach emphasizes tailored coverage at competitive prices, ensuring peace of mind through professional service.

insurance
commercial insurance
personal insurance
auto insurance
property insurance
liability insurance
workers compensation
health care insurance
rental insurance
umbrella insurance
cyber liability
specialty coverage
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1958
Twin Forks Insurance Agency logo

Twin Forks Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 16 Station Road Suite # 7 Bellport, New York 11713, US

Specializing in a wide range of insurance solutions, this agency offers expertise in commercial, liquor liability, builders, nightclub, and restaurant insurance, alongside personal home, auto, and marine coverage. With over 20 years of experience, it emphasizes building trust through personalized service and comprehensive support for diverse insurance needs.

insurance
commercial
liquor liability
builders
nightclub
restaurant
home
auto
marine
Company size: 2-10
Vogel & Moore Agency logo

Vogel & Moore Agency

🇺🇸 13 Wheeler Ave Warwick, New York 10990, US

Vogel & Moore Insurance Agency specializes in providing a wide range of customized insurance solutions, including auto, home, life, and commercial insurance. With innovative services like 24/7 claims support and the Nationwide AutoWatch program, they prioritize client needs and simplify the claims process for comprehensive asset protection.

insurance
auto
home
life
business
commercial
health
renters
motorcycle
claims
coverage
financial
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 1979
Anthony Petrozzella - State Farm Agent logo

Anthony Petrozzella - State Farm Agent

🇺🇸 244-27 Merrick Blvd. Rosedale, NY 11422, US

Specializing in a wide range of insurance products, this firm focuses on helping individuals and businesses manage everyday risks and recover from unexpected events. With a mission to support clients in achieving their dreams, it offers innovative solutions across auto, home, life, and business insurance sectors.

insurance
auto
home
renters
business
life
financial
risk management
health
commercial
personal
umbrella
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1990
Emond Richardson - State Farm Insurance Agent logo

Emond Richardson - State Farm Insurance Agent

🇺🇸 2509 Avenue U Brooklyn, New York 11229, US

Specializing in a comprehensive range of insurance and financial services, this agency offers innovative solutions for auto, home, life, business, and health insurance needs, backed by a highly trained team and exceptional claims service. Their commitment to accessibility and customer support sets them apart in the insurance industry.

insurance
auto
home
life
health
business
disability
claims
financial services
general liability
workers compensation
commercial auto
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2016
Empire Insurance Agency logo

Empire Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 4100 vestal road suite 102

Empire Insurance Agency is an independent insurance provider specializing in a wide range of coverage options, including auto, home, business, and life insurance. Its unique approach allows agents to customize policies from multiple insurers, ensuring tailored solutions that meet the specific needs of clients.

insurance
auto
home
business
renters
boat
motorcycle
life
flood
collector car
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 2009
New York Motor Insurance logo

New York Motor Insurance

🇺🇸 154 Grand St New York, NY 10013, US

Specializing in auto insurance, this innovative insurance broker utilizes a comparison tool to help customers find the best rates, aiming to lower car insurance costs for New Yorkers.

insurance
auto
car
quotes
comparison
broker
rates
savings
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2011
Grober Imbey Insurance Agency logo

Grober Imbey Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 1 Sunrise Highway Valley Stream, New York 11580, US

Specializing in tailored insurance solutions, this agency offers a comprehensive range of services, including homeowners, business, life, and specialized insurance products. With partnerships across over 30 major insurance carriers, it emphasizes personalized service and risk management to meet the unique needs of clients in the Tri-State region.

insurance
risk management
life insurance
health insurance
homeowners insurance
business insurance
auto insurance
commercial insurance
cyber liability
fine art insurance
coastal property insurance
financial services
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1974
Royal Brokerage logo

Royal Brokerage

🇺🇸 1 John Street Ste 200

Royal Brokerage specializes in providing personalized insurance solutions, including auto, home, and commercial coverage, with a focus on tailored analysis and responsive customer service. Their innovative approach emphasizes a customized experience to meet individual insurance needs.

insurance
auto insurance
home insurance
business insurance
coverage
personalized service
risk assessment
policy analysis
claims support
Company size: 2-10
Blue Line Insurance Agency logo

Blue Line Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 55 Barn Road Suite 204 Lake Placid, New York 12946, US

Blue Line Insurance Agency is an independent insurance provider specializing in a comprehensive range of personal and commercial insurance coverages, including auto, homeowners, and life insurance. Their innovative approach features a dedicated team of experts who work collaboratively to deliver tailored solutions and efficient service to clients.

insurance
personal insurance
auto insurance
homeowners insurance
motorcycle insurance
boat insurance
renters insurance
umbrella insurance
life insurance
general liability
workers compensation
disability insurance
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 2011
Benz Associates, LLC logo

Benz Associates, LLC

🇺🇸 36 Buffalo Street Hamburg, NY 14075, US

Benz Associates, LLC is an independent insurance agency specializing in a wide range of coverage options, including auto, home, business, and life insurance. With a strong emphasis on customer service and tailored solutions, they strive to simplify the insurance-buying process while ensuring clients receive the best value for their coverage needs.

insurance
auto
home
business
life
motorcycle
recreational vehicle
workers compensation
liability
flood
renters
commercial
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 1983
Peters Insurance Agency logo

Peters Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 3306 Spring Court North Tonawanda, New York 14120, US

An independent insurance agency specializing in auto, home, and business insurance, offering clients tailored coverage options from a select group of reputable carriers. Their client-focused approach ensures dedicated support during claims, emphasizing fair and prompt service.

insurance
independent agents
auto insurance
home insurance
business insurance
coverage
claims assistance
competitive pricing
insurance carriers
Company size: 1
Founded: 2015
TFG Home & Auto logo

TFG Home & Auto

🇺🇸 305 Spindrift Dr Buffalo, New York 14221, US

TFG Home & Auto is a full-service insurance agency specializing in home, auto, recreational vehicle, and business insurance. With a unique approach of comparing over 25 insurance providers, it aims to deliver optimal coverage at the best rates for its clients.

insurance
auto
home
life
business
recreational vehicle
umbrella
workers compensation
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2018

Updated on

Let our AI browse all websites for you

Save time, improve accuracy, and get ahead of the competition with Cenco.ai.

Get started

You might be interested in