Top 25 Auto Insurance Companies in Wisconsin

5 min read

Get started

Trusted by data-driven investors

Discover the top 25 auto insurance companies in Wisconsin, showcasing a diverse range of coverage options from personal to commercial insurance. These firms, including Glen Oaks Insurance Group and Ansay & Associates, emphasize tailored solutions and risk management strategies to meet unique client needs. Whether you seek comprehensive auto coverage or specialized services, these leading agencies combine local expertise with innovative offerings to provide competitive pricing and exceptional customer service.

Glen Oaks Insurance Group logo

Glen Oaks Insurance Group

🇺🇸 Cottage Grove, Wisconsin 53527, US

Glen Oaks Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency specializing in a wide range of personal and commercial insurance solutions, including auto, home, life, and business insurance. By partnering with strategically selected insurance providers, it offers tailored coverage options that balance quality and affordability for diverse individual and business needs.

insurance
auto
home
life
commercial
farm
bonds
annuities
coverage
recreational vehicle
restaurant
umbrella
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2018
Coverra Insurance logo

Coverra Insurance

🇺🇸 535 Industrial Drive PO Box 253

Coverra Insurance specializes in providing customized insurance solutions, including home, auto, business, and specialty coverage, tailored to meet individual needs while ensuring competitive rates from A-rated insurers. Their innovative approach focuses on delivering personalized advice to help clients make informed decisions about their insurance needs and financial protection.

insurance
coverage
home insurance
auto insurance
business insurance
life insurance
health insurance
flood insurance
specialty insurance
risk management
financial protection
customized plans
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1984
Forward Insurance logo

Forward Insurance

🇺🇸 1001 N Central Ave Marshfield, Wisconsin 54449, US

An independent insurance agency specializing in a wide range of coverage options, including auto, home, business, farm, health, and life insurance, with a commitment to providing personalized service and value-driven protection tailored to the needs of local communities. The agency prioritizes partnerships with insurers that share its dedication to community welfare and customer satisfaction.

insurance
auto
home
business
farm
health
life
coverage
value
independent agency
community protection
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1927

P & C Insurance Services

🇺🇸 405 N CALHOUN RD Brookfield, Wisconsin 53005, us

P & C Insurance Services offers comprehensive insurance solutions encompassing home, auto, business, senior, and life insurance, emphasizing tailored coverage to meet diverse client needs.

insurance
coverage
home insurance
auto insurance
business insurance
life insurance
senior insurance
Company size: 2-10
Baer Insurance Services, Inc. logo

Baer Insurance Services, Inc.

🇺🇸 9701 Brader Way Middleton, WI 53562, US

Baer Insurance Services specializes in providing tailored insurance solutions, including auto, home, business, life, and employee benefits, emphasizing quality coverage and exceptional personal service. With a commitment to evaluating clients' specific needs, it connects them with superior products and fast claims service, ensuring optimal value and protection.

insurance
coverage
personal service
auto insurance
home insurance
business insurance
life insurance
employee benefits
claims service
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1928
Ansay & Associates logo

Ansay & Associates

🇺🇸 101 E Grand Avenue Suite 11

A premier independent insurance agency specializing in commercial and personal insurance, offering a comprehensive range of services including loss control guidance, OSHA training, and employee benefits. Their innovative approach, known as "The Ansay Way," ensures tailored coverage to meet diverse client needs while emphasizing risk management and proactive support.

insurance
commercial
personal
employee benefits
risk management
loss control
crime coverage
OSHA training
auto insurance
home insurance
bundled policies
consulting
Company size: 201-500
Founded: 1946
Noah Insurance Group logo

Noah Insurance Group

🇺🇸 234 Keller Avenue S P.O. Box 107

Noah Insurance Group specializes in providing personalized insurance solutions across various sectors, including personal, commercial, and employee benefits. With a focus on understanding client needs and offering tailored coverage at competitive prices, it emphasizes exceptional customer service and a comprehensive range of insurance products.

insurance
personal insurance
commercial insurance
employee benefits
risk management
auto insurance
home insurance
motorcycle insurance
umbrella insurance
life insurance
health insurance
small business insurance
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1982

An independent insurance agency specializing in auto, home, and business insurance, offering competitive pricing by representing multiple reputable insurance providers. Its unique approach focuses on personalized service, ensuring clients receive tailored coverage that best fits their individual needs.

insurance
auto insurance
home insurance
business insurance
independent agency
coverage
competitive pricing
risk management
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 1979
Financial, Homeowners, Business, Commercial, Agricultural, Toys - In Control Broker Insurance Agency logo

Financial, Homeowners, Business, Commercial, Agricultural, Toys - In Control Broker Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 437 S Yellowstone Dr 120

An independent insurance agency specializing in a diverse range of coverage options, including personal, commercial, agricultural, and recreational insurance. By partnering with over 40 top-rated insurers, it offers tailored solutions that prioritize client needs and competitive pricing.

insurance
independent agents
commercial insurance
personal insurance
agri-business
recreational insurance
liability coverage
property coverage
risk management
collector vehicles
competitive pricing
policy comparison
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2002
Esch Insurance Agency, Inc. logo

Esch Insurance Agency, Inc.

🇺🇸 322 N. Iowa Street PO Box 110

Esch Insurance Agency, Inc. is a full-service independent insurance agency specializing in a wide range of insurance products, including home, auto, business, and health coverage. With a commitment to personalized service and value, it offers clients the ability to compare multiple insurance options while providing ongoing support and tailored solutions to meet their evolving needs.

insurance
coverage
claims
home insurance
auto insurance
business insurance
health insurance
life insurance
renters insurance
value comparison
independent agency
customer service
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 1959
Jeremy White Insurance logo

Jeremy White Insurance

🇺🇸 105 1/2 S Main St Cuba City, WI 53807, US

An independent insurance agency specializing in auto, home, and business insurance, offering competitive pricing and tailored coverage options by representing multiple reputable insurance providers. Their unique approach prioritizes client needs over any single insurer, ensuring personalized solutions for a variety of insurance requirements.

insurance
auto
home
motorcycle
umbrella
boat
renters
commercial
Company size: 1
Wisconsin Association of Mutual Insurance Companies logo

Wisconsin Association of Mutual Insurance Companies

🇺🇸 7203 Gene Street Suite A

A trade association representing 61 small mutual insurance providers, this organization focuses on advocating for and supporting the unique needs of mutual insurance companies in the insurance industry. Its innovative approach emphasizes collaboration among small insurers to enhance service delivery and policyholder coverage.

insurance
trade association
mutual insurance
policyholders
coverage
Wisconsin
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 1913
Thiel Insurance Group, LLC logo

Thiel Insurance Group, LLC

🇺🇸 620 N Richmond St Appleton, WI 54911, US

An independent insurance agency specializing in a wide range of coverage options, including auto, home, business, and life insurance, Thiel Insurance Group leverages partnerships with multiple reputable insurers to tailor solutions that meet individual client needs at competitive prices. Their unique approach focuses on client advocacy, ensuring personalized service rather than representing a single insurance provider.

insurance
auto
home
business
life
motorcycle
umbrella
boat
renters
commercial
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 1960
Leonard Insurance logo

Leonard Insurance

🇺🇸 1317 W Towne Square Rd Mequon, Wisconsin 53092, US

Leonard Insurance is an independent insurance agency specializing in auto, home, and business insurance, offering tailored coverage solutions at competitive prices. With the ability to represent multiple reputable insurers, it provides personalized service that prioritizes the client's needs over any single insurance provider.

insurance
auto
home
motorcycle
umbrella
boat
renters
commercial
coverage
independent agency
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1963
Oshkosh Insurance Agency, Inc. logo

Oshkosh Insurance Agency, Inc.

🇺🇸 310 W Irving Ave Oshkosh, Wisconsin 54901, US

An independent insurance agency specializing in a wide range of coverage options, including auto, home, life, health, and business insurance, with a focus on personalized service and advocacy for clients during claims. With over 20 years of experience, it partners with reputable insurance providers to deliver tailored policies at competitive prices.

insurance
auto
home
life
health
business
workers compensation
commercial
group benefits
personal
independent agency
coverage
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2004

Delain Insurance Agency specializes in providing personal and commercial insurance solutions, including flood, home, and auto insurance. Leveraging its membership in a cluster of agencies, it offers clients access to top insurance providers, resulting in lower costs, enhanced service, and a wider range of options.

insurance
personal insurance
commercial insurance
flood insurance
home insurance
auto insurance
risk management
client service
coverage options
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 1982
Abel Insurance logo

Abel Insurance

🇺🇸 1 Bank Ave Kaukauna, Wisconsin 54130, US

An independent insurance agency specializing in a wide range of coverage options, including commercial and personal insurance, with a focus on building strong relationships and community engagement to meet clients' unique needs.

insurance
coverage
liability
commercial
property
auto
workers' comp
recreational
umbrella
events
agents
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 1967
GOEBEL Insurance & Financial logo

GOEBEL Insurance & Financial

🇺🇸 131 N Rolling Meadows Dr Suite A

GOEBEL Insurance & Financial operates as an independent insurance agency, specializing in a wide range of coverage options including auto, home, and business insurance. Its unique approach allows for tailored solutions by representing multiple reputable insurers, ensuring competitive pricing and personalized service for clients.

insurance
auto
home
business
motorcycle
umbrella
boat
renters
commercial
life
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1994
Burstad Insurance logo

Burstad Insurance

🇺🇸 420 Main St E Menomonie, Wisconsin 54751, US

Burstad Insurance is an independent insurance agency specializing in auto, home, and business insurance, offering tailored coverage options from multiple reputable insurers. Its unique approach allows for personalized service and competitive pricing, ensuring clients receive the best-fit solutions for their insurance needs.

insurance
auto
home
business
coverage
independent agency
competitive pricing
financial stability
risk management
client advocacy
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 1994
Glass Insurance Center logo

Glass Insurance Center

🇺🇸 500 Commercial Ct Ste 500

An independent insurance agency specializing in auto, home, and business insurance, offering tailored coverage solutions from a variety of reputable providers at competitive prices. Its unique approach prioritizes client needs, ensuring personalized service and optimal coverage options.

insurance
auto
home
business
motorcycle
umbrella
boat
commercial
life
small business
restaurant
contractors
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 1931
C4 Insurance Services, LLC logo

C4 Insurance Services, LLC

🇺🇸 8446 Excelsior Dr 2

C4 Insurance Services specializes in providing a wide range of insurance products, including home, auto, and business coverage, while emphasizing education and personalized service for value-conscious consumers. As independent agents, they offer diverse options tailored to meet individual client needs, fostering long-lasting relationships.

insurance
coverage
liability
home insurance
auto insurance
life insurance
business insurance
workers compensation
umbrella insurance
watercraft insurance
client education
independent agents
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2017

Tricor Insurance specializes in providing a range of insurance products, including life, auto, health, and home insurance, with a focus on offering competitive quotes tailored to individual needs. The innovative approach allows customers to easily compare options and find the most affordable coverage based on various factors such as vehicle type and age.

life insurance
auto insurance
health insurance
home insurance
insurance quotes
risk assessment
premium calculation
coverage options
Company size: 1

Specializing in life, auto, health, and home insurance, this organization provides tailored insurance solutions with a focus on delivering competitive quotes based on individual circumstances and vehicle types. Their innovative online platform allows users to easily compare options across multiple states, ensuring the best rates for diverse insurance needs.

insurance
life insurance
auto insurance
health insurance
home insurance
quotes
coverage
premiums
underwriting
risk assessment
liability
Company size: 1
Koss Insurance logo

Koss Insurance

🇺🇸 2998 Bosshard Dr Fitchburg, Wisconsin 53711, US

Koss Insurance operates as an independent insurance agency, specializing in a wide range of coverage options including auto, home, and business insurance. Its unique approach allows for personalized service by representing multiple reputable insurers, ensuring clients receive tailored solutions at competitive prices.

insurance
auto
home
business
motorcycle
umbrella
boat
renters
commercial
life
Company size: 1
Founded: 2003
NS Insurance logo

NS Insurance

🇺🇸 2149 Velp Ave Ste 100

NS Insurance is a modern, independent insurance agency specializing in home, auto, business, and life insurance, focused on enhancing the customer experience through technology and innovative risk management. By prioritizing comprehensive coverage and personalized communication, it aims to simplify the insurance process while adding value to clients' lives.

insurance
auto
home
life
business
risk management
insurance agency
insurance broker
commercial
workers compensation
health
group benefits
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2020

Updated on

Let our AI browse all websites for you

Save time, improve accuracy, and get ahead of the competition with Cenco.ai.

Get started

You might be interested in