Top 24 Auto Insurance Companies in Florida

4 min read

Get started

Trusted by data-driven investors

Explore the top 24 auto insurance companies in Florida, crucial for informed investment decisions among bankers and finance professionals. These companies offer tailored insurance solutions across various sectors, with specialties such as commercial trucking, workers' compensation, and personalized auto coverage. Key players like Pagola Insurance Group and META INSURANCE provide comprehensive options, leveraging partnerships with multiple carriers to ensure optimized policy features and pricing. This review highlights industry focus and geographic strategies relevant to the evolving needs of Florida's insurance market in 2025.

Pagola Insurance Group logo

Pagola Insurance Group

🇺🇸 2525 Ponce de Leon Blvd Suite 300

Pagola Insurance Group specializes in providing tailored commercial and personal auto insurance solutions, leveraging partnerships with multiple carriers to offer competitive pricing and exceptional service. With over 20 years of combined experience, they focus on delivering a diverse range of options to meet client needs, particularly in commercial trucking insurance.

insurance
brokerage
auto insurance
commercial insurance
personal insurance
trucking insurance
policy review
insurance carriers
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2020
Florida Insurance Agency logo

Florida Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 3763 Highway 90 Pace, Florida 32571, US

An independent insurance agency specializing in a wide range of coverage options, including home, auto, commercial, and life insurance, while partnering with top-rated carriers to provide competitive rates and tailored solutions. With a commitment to exceptional service, it aims to protect clients' most valuable assets and ensure peace of mind.

insurance
coverage
home
auto
commercial
life
property
casualty
renters
motorcycle
marine
workers compensation
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1993
Triton Insurance Group Inc. logo

Triton Insurance Group Inc.

🇺🇸 100 N. State Road 7 Suite 304 Margate, Fl 33063, US

Triton Insurance Group specializes in providing a wide range of insurance solutions, including homeowners, auto, business, and specialized coverage, with a focus on personalized service and customer advocacy. Leveraging partnerships with numerous carriers, it offers clients diverse options to ensure optimal policy features and pricing.

insurance
homeowners
auto
business
liability
workers' compensation
flood
equine
umbrella
franchising
customer advocacy
policy options
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1993
Odiorne Insurance Agency logo

Odiorne Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 1206 Parsons Ave N Brandon, Florida 33510, US

An independent insurance agency offering customized insurance solutions for individuals and businesses, leveraging multiple underwriters to provide fast online quotes. Known for personalized service, each client is matched with a dedicated team member for expert guidance across a wide range of personal and commercial insurance products.

insurance
quotes
personal insurance
commercial insurance
auto insurance
homeowners insurance
liability insurance
workers compensation
renters insurance
business insurance
online quotes
independent agency
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1974
Insurance Wagon logo

Insurance Wagon

🇺🇸 2529 University Blvd W Jacksonville, Florida, US

An independent insurance agency specializing in a wide range of coverage options, including auto, home, commercial, and life insurance, while representing over 50 different carriers to offer competitive pricing and tailored solutions. With a decade of experience, it emphasizes savings and personalized service in the insurance industry.

insurance
auto
home
commercial
life
annuities
renters
boat
condo
independent agency
insurance carriers
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2008
Imperial Insurance & Tax logo

Imperial Insurance & Tax

🇺🇸 924 E Sample Rd Pompano Beach, FL 33064, US

An independent insurance agency specializing in a wide range of insurance products, including auto, home, commercial, health, and life insurance, while also offering expert tax services. With a customer-first approach, it ensures clients receive the best coverage at competitive rates by comparing multiple top-rated carriers.

insurance
auto
home
commercial
health
life
coverage
enrollment
workers comp
ACA
ObamaCare
financial decisions
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 2000
Business Insurance Center logo

Business Insurance Center

🇺🇸 6979 Kingspointe Pkwy Orlando, Florida 32819, US

Specializing in a wide range of insurance services, this firm offers tailored personal and commercial coverage options, including auto, home, workers compensation, and health insurance. With a focus on building lasting relationships and a diverse portfolio of policies from multiple carriers, it aims to meet the unique needs of clients across Florida.

insurance
personal lines
commercial lines
auto insurance
home insurance
workers compensation
general liability
health insurance
individual life insurance
business owners policy
coverage
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 1981
Flinsco.com logo

Flinsco.com

🇺🇸 2515 Hollywood Blvd Hollywood, Florida 33020, US

Flinsco specializes in providing a wide range of insurance solutions, including auto, home, and commercial insurance, with a focus on serving working individuals and businesses. Notable for its extensive network of carriers and exceptional customer service, the agency consistently seeks to offer competitive rates and tailored coverage options across Florida.

insurance
auto
home
commercial
workers comp
flood
renters
policies
agents
customer service
liability
Company size: 51-200
Founded: 2009
META INSURANCE logo

META INSURANCE

🇺🇸 COCONUT CREEK, FL 33073, US

Meta Insurance Agency specializes in providing tailored insurance solutions across various sectors, including home, auto, and commercial insurance, by leveraging a wide range of carrier options to ensure clients receive the best coverage and pricing. Their innovative approach emphasizes unbiased advice and personalized service, aiming to meet diverse insurance needs effectively.

insurance
brokerage
coverage
liability
homeowners
commercial
workers' compensation
auto
flood
pricing
carriers
unbiased advice
Company size: 1
Founded: 2023
PlanLife logo

PlanLife

🇺🇸 Windermere Rd Windermere, Florida 34786, US

PlanLife is an independent insurance agency that provides comprehensive insurance solutions for both commercial and personal needs, including a wide range of products such as property, liability, and life insurance. With over 25 years of experience and access to A+ rated carriers, it offers tailored coverage options to meet diverse risk appetites.

insurance
commercial insurance
personal insurance
property insurance
liability insurance
auto insurance
life insurance
workers compensation
umbrella insurance
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2017
MM Insurance - agency of HH Insurance Group logo

MM Insurance - agency of HH Insurance Group

🇺🇸 6727 1st Ave South Suite 101

MM Insurance specializes in providing a comprehensive range of insurance products, including home, flood, auto, marine, and commercial coverage, leveraging extensive industry knowledge to stay ahead of market trends and ensure superior customer service at competitive prices.

insurance
coverage
home insurance
flood insurance
auto insurance
marine insurance
commercial insurance
umbrella insurance
customer experience
marketplace trends
Company size: 2-10
Westgate-Jones Insurance logo

Westgate-Jones Insurance

🇺🇸 3411 W. Main St, Suite 5 Leesburg, Florida 34748, US

Westgate-Jones Insurance is a full-service independent brokerage specializing in personal, commercial, health, auto, and homeowners insurance, offering access to top-rated carriers for competitive rates and superior coverage options. Its locally owned approach ensures a personalized service tailored to meet the unique needs of clients in Florida.

insurance
brokerage
florida
personal
commercial
health
auto
homeowners
carriers
rates
options
agency
service
coverage
providers
independent
local
quality
superior
network
Company size: 11-50
Most Insurance Agency logo

Most Insurance Agency

🇺🇸 3314 W Bay to Bay Blvd TAMPA, Florida 33629, US

Most Insurance Agency specializes in providing personalized insurance solutions across various sectors, including auto, home, business, and life insurance. As an independent agency, it differentiates itself by offering a wide range of options from multiple carriers, ensuring clients receive the best coverage at competitive rates.

insurance
coverage
auto
home
business
life
flood
umbrella
independent agency
carriers
policies
personalized
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 1973
The Insurance Factory logo

The Insurance Factory

🇺🇸 4996 N Pine Island Rd Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33351, US

The Insurance Factory specializes in a comprehensive range of insurance products, including auto, commercial, and workers compensation insurance, along with specialized coverage for boats and motorcycles. Their innovative approach offers tailored solutions for both individual and business needs, ensuring a versatile and customer-focused service.

insurance
auto
commercial
workers compensation
motorcycle
boat
general liability
business insurance
professional liability
contractors insurance
business owners policy
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2021
Regency Insurance Group, LLC logo

Regency Insurance Group, LLC

🇺🇸 24311 Walden Center Dr Ste 103

An independent insurance agency specializing in a wide range of coverage options, including home, auto, and business insurance, dedicated to providing personalized service and value by partnering with multiple insurance providers to offer clients tailored solutions.

insurance
home insurance
auto insurance
business insurance
life insurance
health insurance
renters insurance
flood insurance
liability insurance
disability insurance
worker's compensation
marine insurance
Company size: 51-200
Founded: 2011
The Insurance Store logo

The Insurance Store

🇺🇸 5119 Memorial Hwy Tampa, Florida 33634, US

A full-service independent insurance agency specializing in a wide range of coverage options, including auto, homeowners, and renters insurance. Known for its extensive network of providers and commitment to customer service, it focuses on delivering tailored insurance solutions with integrity and respect.

insurance
brokerage
independent agent
auto insurance
homeowners insurance
renters insurance
flood insurance
coverage options
customer service
insurance specialists
insurance carriers
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 1996
Finney Insurance Corporation logo

Finney Insurance Corporation

🇺🇸 5601 Sheridan Street Hollywood, FL 33021, US

An independent insurance agency specializing in auto, home, and business insurance, offering tailored solutions by connecting clients with quality carriers at affordable prices. Its innovative approach focuses on understanding individual client needs to provide a diverse range of insurance products.

insurance
auto
home
business
agency
carriers
coverage
premiums
claims
policies
independent
affordability
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2009
Evergreen Insurance logo

Evergreen Insurance

🇺🇸 583 105th Ave N Suite 2

Evergreen Insurance is an independent insurance agency that specializes in providing tailored insurance solutions across various sectors, including commercial and personal coverage. With a focus on exceptional customer service and a commitment to building long-lasting relationships, the agency leverages over a century of combined experience to offer competitive premiums by comparing multiple carriers.

insurance
commercial insurance
personal insurance
general liability
workers compensation
property insurance
homeowners insurance
auto insurance
umbrella insurance
professional liability
insurance consulting
Company size: 11-50
Founded: 2006

Denise Vanegas - GreatFlorida Insurance

🇺🇸 2567 EAST IRLO BRONSON MEMORIAL HWY Kissimmee, Florida 34744, us

An insurance agency specializing in a wide range of coverage options, including auto, home, health, and commercial insurance, while partnering with top carriers to provide competitive rates and hassle-free quotes.

insurance
auto
home
health
life
renters
liability
flood
commercial
property
boat
quotes
Company size: 2-10
Cataleya Insurance logo

Cataleya Insurance

🇺🇸 11865 SW 26th St Suite A-9

Cataleya Insurance specializes in providing comprehensive insurance solutions for individuals and businesses, focusing on wealth and health protection through policy contracting and claims administration. Their innovative advisory approach helps clients select the best coverage options across various insurance specialties, including health, auto, property, and life insurance.

insurance
health insurance
car insurance
auto insurance
property insurance
residential insurance
life insurance
commercial insurance
claims administration
policy contracting
advisory services
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2021
New Auto Insurance logo

New Auto Insurance

🇺🇸 Florida, US

Offering innovative and customized auto insurance solutions, this provider emphasizes quick quotes, reliable coverage, and fast claims service, leveraging advanced technology to enhance customer experience and support informed decision-making.

auto insurance
coverage
claims service
customized quotes
affordable rates
policy options
insurance technology
market advantage
Company size: 51-200
QuotesMatch.com logo

QuotesMatch.com

🇺🇸 Hallandale, Florida 33008, US

QuotesMatch.com operates as a car insurance comparison marketplace, facilitating quick and easy access to competitive insurance quotes by connecting consumers with a wide network of agencies, brokers, and carriers. Its innovative approach streamlines the insurance selection process, making it more efficient for users to find optimal auto and home insurance options.

car insurance
comparison marketplace
quotes
competitive rates
insurance agencies
insurance brokers
insurance carriers
auto insurance
home insurance
consumer matching
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2016
Omni One Insurance Agency LLC logo

Omni One Insurance Agency LLC

🇺🇸 4707 SE 9th Pl Cape Coral, Florida 33904, US

An independent insurance agency offering a comprehensive range of traditional and specialty insurance services, utilizing multiple carriers to secure tailored coverage and competitive pricing for clients, including those with previous denials. Their innovative approach provides peace of mind by ensuring access to diverse insurance solutions for various needs, from home and auto to commercial and specialty coverage.

insurance
brokerage
coverage
auto
home
commercial
liability
workers comp
specialty
quotes
independent
carriers
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 2020
Safe Insurance Group logo

Safe Insurance Group

🇺🇸 7901 NW 2 ST Miami, Florida 33126, US

An independent insurance agency specializing in a wide range of personal and business insurance solutions, offering tailored policies that combine competitive pricing with comprehensive coverage. Notably, it excels in classic car insurance and various commercial insurance options, leveraging a vast network of leading carriers to meet diverse client needs.

insurance
auto
homeowners
commercial
liability
workers compensation
life
health
motorcycle
flood
boat
Company size: 2-10
Founded: 1989

Updated on

Let our AI browse all websites for you

Save time, improve accuracy, and get ahead of the competition with Cenco.ai.

Get started

You might be interested in